Post Reply  Post Thread 

Task Suggestion: Anonymous Witnesses

Author Message

Post: #1
Task Suggestion: Anonymous Witnesses

Following a string of controversial criminal court cases there has been growing debate among the public about the role of anonymous witnesses in criminal trials. Senior figures are demanding action.

Option 1. "Victims of crime & other witnesses are failing to testify at trial in alarming numbers. These wretches - criminals - will deploy any tactic to try & intimidate witnesses, including violence. Prosecutors alone are best placed to determine whether a witness should be able to give evidence anonymously!" Exclaims the well known right wing prosecutor Jeremy Vile.

Option 2. "Wait a minute, you bloody hound" retorts Dr Pannash who recently had his conviction for murder overturned because the sole piece of evidence implicating him was a report given by an anonymous witness. "I was almost sent to jail for murder based on accusations made by someone who didn't dare & show me their face. The right to confront your accuser is a key safeguard in our legal system & with good reason, people should appreciate the gravity of what they're doing when they give evidence against another! This practice ought to be completely banned or reserved for cases of organised crime!"

Option 3. "I don't want to be rude but you gentleman are both wrong" celebrated regional judge Gayner interjects. "Of course prosecutors cannot decide when a witness shall give evidence anonymously, this would be a severe conflict of interest and an over extension of the practice. But, to suggest that anonymous evidence should be confined to cases of organised crime is also naive; of course witnesses in cases of sexual abuse & violent crime will be vulnerable & the law ought to reflect that. Whether a witness can give evidence anonymously ought to be a matter for a judge to decide on a case by case basis, with strict procedural guidelines in place & the interests of the parties being borne in mind."


Option 1. The criminal courts are swamped with cases as those with grudges can simply make incriminating allegations against others & do not have to have regard to the consequences. As a result of this mayhem judges are reluctant to impose harsh sentences on those who are found guilty & prisoners walk three after a few months.
(Crime rises & civil rights fall)

Option 2. Witnesses cannot be granted anonymity outside of organised crime cases & are thus reluctant to testify. Both innocent and guilty men walk free as a result.
(Crime rises but there is a modest rise in civil rights)

Option 3. Judges allow special categories of 'vulnerable' witnesses to give anonymous evidence securing key convictions, whilst maintaining the general principle that an accused has right to face those testifying against him.
(Crime decreases and there is a more noticeable rise in civil rights as both the accused & the witness are protected)

10.11.2015 14:58
Quote this message in a reply

Posts: 8,854
Words count: 1,597,451
Group: Super Moderators
Joined: Nov2008
Status: Offline
Reputation: 146
Experience: 859
Glory Points: 260
Medals: 11

Post: #2
RE: Task Suggestion: Anonymous Witnesses

Nice suggestion. I'm for it. Would have chosen option 3 even if you hadn't posted the consequences. Hehe

This post was last modified: 10.11.2015 16:42 by Helsworth.

10.11.2015 15:56
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply  Post Thread 

Possibly Related Threads...
Thread: Author Replies: Views: Last Post
  Suggestion: Education reform nike1155 2 1,383 24.10.2018 11:10
Last Post: Sylvia Stevens
  Task Freedom to Strike hamma13 1 1,033 24.10.2018 11:07
Last Post: Sylvia Stevens
  Task Tuition fees hamma13 1 906 24.10.2018 11:01
Last Post: Sylvia Stevens
  Task Polygamy hamma13 3 910 13.02.2018 10:43
Last Post: MrProper
  Task Labor Unions hamma13 1 1,121 05.10.2017 16:11
Last Post: MrProper
  Task Emissions Trading hamma13 2 1,130 24.08.2017 09:31
Last Post: hamma13
  Task Electricity Tariff (Economy, Infrastructure) hamma13 2 1,051 14.07.2017 03:46
Last Post: Alexei B.Miller
  I have a suggestion! Alexei B.Miller 0 1,240 07.06.2017 03:41
Last Post: Alexei B.Miller
  Suggestion: Police State reform Ajay Alcos 6 1,541 13.04.2016 13:14
Last Post: yangusbeef
  Suggestion: Money Reform III Lizard25 20 3,674 04.12.2015 16:35
Last Post: Helsworth

View a Printable Version
Send this Thread to a Friend
Subscribe to this Thread | Add Thread to Favorites

Forum Jump: